Help identifying a font

Font Identification
1

I’ve tried the matcherator here and a few others with no luck. It’s the A and the R that look unique to me. I would appreciate any help! Thank you!

Orono General Store.JPG773×250 27.7 KB

2

I don’t believe this is it but it is really close:

3

I think this actually may be it:

4

@joe always one-upping me. @dreamer458 sorry this took so long. We really let you down.